Book a Demo burger-menu-icon
Book a Demo

Offline conversion tracking – key challenges

Offline conversion tracking

offline conversion tracking

Is there a mismatch between the conversions you are tracking and the actual revenue you are targeting?

Measuring CAC when you don’t really have a customer yet?

For many businesses, their digital marketing conversions are only leads or potential clients with wide variations in actual revenue. Let us look at a few examples.

  • If you are an optician, your conversions from digital marketing are largely bookings, typically a eyesight test. However, the revenue from the test can range from nothing (no-show) to repeat orders of expensive prescription glasses and more.
  • Similarly, if you are a financial services provider, your conversion from digital marketing is typically an application form for a loan. The actual revenues and results however depend on later events such as approval, interest rates and performance of the customer.
  • A SaaS business or anyone selling subscription services measures conversions as new subscribers. How long do they however stay, typically after an introductory discount period?

Tracking and measurement of campaigns and ads typically only provides the cost (CAC) for potential revenues. Most businesses simply accept this as a fact of life and carry on their digital marketing activities with a view to minimize the cost of a booking, application or new subscription. The actual revenue generation is left as a different business altogether.

The devil is in the details

If you simply measure and optimize the cost for potential revenues, you run the risk of attracting the wrong kind of customer. Let us say that you have two campaigns with widely different conversion costs. Without additional information, you would discontinue the high-cost campaign. However, the expensive campaign could provide potential customers that spend more, stay longer and perform better. Correspondingly, the low-cost campaign can provide potential customers that you really don’t want, like bargain hunters, no-shows and loan defaulters.

Trying to bridge the gap

There are different ways to partially mitigate the information gap. As you probably have guessed, excel sheets and hard work are key elements. The challenge with these alternatives is that they require a lot of time and effort and hence do not allow for adjustments before the campaign has ended and the money has been spent.

Google provides some ideas on how to track offline conversions. The idea of posting data back to Google however raises the issue of GDPR compliance. Additionally, as Google is phasing out third-party cookies, perhaps the effort will no longer be worthwhile.

Measure what matters real-time with Digtective

The marketing software Digtective provides a real-time overview of the performance of your digital marketing activities. Measuring customer acquisition costs directly against customer lifetime value is now possible, and you can optimize your marketing spend towards profits instead of an uncertain proxy (leads). Digtective also bridges the gap for offline conversions by connecting with your CRM so you can compare your digital marketing spend real-time against any relevant metric or combinations of metrics.

Relax, Digtective does not exchange personal data and is GDPR compliant. No third-party cookies, no javascript, no fingerprinting.

Getting Started is Easy

Turn data into growth. Connect marketing and sales effortlessly and unlock insights that drive ROI.

What are you waiting for?
Track with precision, convert with confidence, and make every ad dollar count.

The end of third party cookies may not be the end…

The End of Third-Party Cookies: A New Beginning for Smarter Marketing

Google to phase out third-party cookies

As most marketers will have noticed, Google is to phase out third-party cookies by 2022. Firefox, Mozilla and Safari have blocked third-party cookies for years – one of the reasons why tracking has already become difficult. According to Google, the move to phase out cookies is based on privacy concerns. Critics have however argued that Google is opting for even more control of the ad market, as they will still collect personal data and sell access to “cohorts” of users. But that is a different discussion, and does not solve the problem at hand for marketers.

GDPR has already made tracking difficult

Third-party cookies have been under pressure for some time. For those of us who must comply with GDPR and explicit cookie-consents, the availability of data for tracking advertising ROI has deteriorated significantly. Cookie-blockers and javascript-blockers have not helped the situation. Europe is not the only jurisdiction where cookie-consent is required, and certainly not the last.

What now for marketers?

Whilst waiting for Google’s next solutions, the marketing community seems to have formed a consensus that future focus should be on contextual marketing, content marketing and consent-based solutions. This is undoubtedly good advice, however not an easy change for E-commerce marketers that have focused heavily or maybe even exclusively on cookie-based optimization of their digital marketing activities.

Google’s 5 pillars of a holistic marketing measurement plan

In a post from January 2021, Google suggests 1) Leverage the power of first-party data, 2) Bring first-party data together with cross-platform tools, 3) Be transparent about data usage with your customers, 4) Fill measurement gaps with modeled data and 5) Predict customer behavior with a secure cloud-based solution. Again sound advice, but not a quick fix.

Cookieless tracking

In recent years, new technologies for tracking have been developed that do not use third-party cookies. “Cookieless tracking” can be confusing, as it is partly used as a term for analyzing website traffic without knowing the referrals for the visit. Cookieless tracking technologies are however attempting to harvest data that has similar value for a marketer as do third-party cookies. Cookieless tracking utilizes scripts that run when a user visits a web page but does not store information on the user’s browser device. The user remains anonymous, and cross-tracking is impossible. Without accessing or storing personal data these technologies add significant value to a digital marketer.

Fingerprinting is cookieless, but…

Fingerprinting has been around for many years, and its use has increased significantly, partly as cookie-consent requirements have increased. A digital fingerprint is created when a company makes a unique profile of you based on your computer hardware, software, add-ons, and even preferences. etc. The practice of fingerprinting allows tracking for months, even when the user clears the browser storage or uses private browsing mode. The first problem is that this works as a third-party cookie, without ever asking for the user’s consent. The second problem is that Google will block it as they view is as a workaround of the third-party cookie ban. Again, Mozilla, Firefox and Safari were ahead of Google in this regard.

Digtective: the solution for continued tracking without cookies

Digtective is a marketing software that is not based on cookies or fingerprinting, nor collects personalized data of any kind. Digtective offers 100% accurate and updated information on the performance of your campaigns and ads, enabling marketers to stop any marketing activity that is not producing the required conversions and spend more of their budget on profit-generating ads and campaigns. Digtective can be set up with an API to your CRM system without exchanging personal data, providing the opportunity to measure any post-sale metric such as recurring revenue, returns and defaults against customer acquisition costs.

Getting Started is Easy

Turn data into growth. Connect marketing and sales effortlessly and unlock insights that drive ROI.

What are you waiting for?
Track with precision, convert with confidence, and make every ad dollar count.